Court Gives White House a Choice: Pull Out of Christmas Pageant or Remove Nativity

Timeline of History

History Topics
Religious History
Political History
Church & State History
Countries

The US Court of Appeals gives the White House a choice: to pull out of the Christmas Pageant of Peace held every year or to remove a nativity scene.

This decision ends a lawsuit filed four years ago by an Episcopal minister, the president of the American Ethical Union, a rabbi, a Catholic priest, and an atheist. The plaintiffs had sought a complete ban on the nativity scene in the pageant.

Instead of imposing such a ban, judges Edward A. Tamm, Harold Leventhal, and Roger Robb create a set of conditions under which government participation in the Christmas pageant would be constitutional.

In the decision, Judge Leventhal rejects the conclusion of a lower court that the secular context of the nativity scene reduces its religious nature:

"What seems equally, if not more, likely is that the commercial establishments that display the nativity scene, a clearly religious symbol, do so in order to evoke its emotional message, as a motivation for purchase of contemporary equivalents of frankincense and myrrh."
Powered by JReviews

Today's Major Events

100,000 Japanese Americans Interned Until End of WWII
John Ashcroft Implies Atheists Aren't Civilized at Religious Convention
 Boerne v. Flores: Court Rules RFRA is Unconstitutional

February History Calendar

September History Calendar