Elkhart v. Brooks: 10 Commandments Monument in Indiana Ruled Unconstitutional

Elkhart v. Brooks: 10 Commandments Monument in Indiana Ruled Unconstitutional

Ten Commandments Monument in Elkhart, Indiana, 2000

Timeline of History

History Topics
Religious History

Argued: Elkhart vs. Brooks — The 7th Circuit Court will rule that a Fraternal Order of Eagles Ten Commandments monument at an Indian city hall was unconstitutional. The U.S. Supreme Court will later let this ruling stand when it is appealed to them.

The 7th Circuit Court ruling will say, in part:

"In accepting the monument, the City...aimed to provide a code of conduct for the citizens of Elkhart to follow. The code chosen, however, was a religious code that focuses not only on subjects that are the legitimate concern of civil authorities, but also subjects that are beyond the ken of any government and that address directly the relationship of the individual human being and God.

That the purpose was to endorse, through governmental sponsorship, a code of religious values is further established by the program of speakers at the dedication of the monument: a Protestant minister, a Catholic priest, and a Jewish rabbi. ...

Indeed, this monument impermissibly suggests that, in this community, there are "ins" and "outs." The monument contains the Stars of David and the symbol of Christ, representing respectively Judaism and Christianity, two of the religions no doubt particularly represented in the Elkhart community, but by no means the total of all those who depend on the City of Elkhart as their local government."

Read More: Elkhart vs. Brooks


If the Ten Commandment monument is legal then how about a Koran Monument?

User comments

There are no user comments for this item.

Ratings (the higher the better)
    Please enter the security code.
Powered by JReviews

Today's Major Events

Operation Barbarossa, Invasion of Soviet Union, is Launched by Nazi Germany
ACLU Will Try to Raise $10,000 for Defense of John Scopes for Teaching Evolution
Birth of Erich Marie Remarque, Author of All Quiet On The Western Front
Vatican Condemns U.S. States Outlawing Discrimination Due to Sexual Orientation
Second Armistice at Compiègne Signed Between Germany and Remains of French Government