U.S. v. Eichmann: Government Cannot Ban Flag Burning Hot

U.S. v. Eichmann: Government Cannot Ban Flag Burning

Flag Burning

Timeline of History

History Topics

Argued: United States v. Eichman — The U.S. Supreme Court will rule 5-4 that the government cannot ban flag burning.

This case combines two cases of people who burned flags in protest against the Flag Protection Act of 1989, passed by Congress after the Supreme Court's Texas v. Johnson decision, which ruled that flag burning is constitutionally protected.

Justice William J. Brennan writes in the majority decision:

"[T]he Government's asserted interest in protecting the "physical integrity" of a privately owned flag in order to preserve the flag's status as a symbol of the Nation and certain national ideals is related to the suppression, and concerned with the content, of free expression.

The mere destruction or disfigurement of a symbol's physical manifestation does not diminish or otherwise affect the symbol itself.

The Government's interest is implicated only when a person's treatment of the flag communicates a message to others that is inconsistent with the identified ideals.

The precise language of the Act's prohibitions confirms Congress' interest in the communicative impact of flag destruction, since each of the specified terms — with the possible exception of "burns" — unmistakably connotes disrespectful treatment of the flag and suggests a focus on those acts likely to damage the flag's symbolic value, and since the explicit exemption for disposal of "worn or soiled" flags protects certain acts traditionally associated with patriotic respect for the flag. [emphasis added]"

Read More: United States v Eichman


United States vs. Eichman

User comments

There are no user comments for this item.

Ratings (the higher the better)
    Please enter the security code.
Powered by JReviews

Today's Major Events

Dominican Friar Girolamo Savonarola Executed by Being Burned Alive
Taliban Orders Minorities to Wear Identifying tags in Afghanistan
Thomas Cranmer Voids Marriage of Henry VIII to Catherine of Aragon
Pope Paul III Starts Portuguese Inquisition
Adolf Eichmann's Capture in Argentina Announced by David Ben-Gurion